Honeymoon: Undecided

So, we didn't think we'd be able to go on a honeymoon. First, we really wanted to go to Costa Rica... plane tickets are $1,000 each. Then we really wanted to go to Clear Lake California (I'd still LOVE to go some day) to go hike in the mountains, fish, and go to wineries. Plane tickets are >$500 each. So, we talked about what we want: to fish, to hike, to be able to go to dinner, but to be secluded. We have both vacationed in Tennessee and loved it. So, we decided that TN is it. It is affordable and beautiful.

The problem is... we know nothing about Tennessee. We have narrowed it down to 3 places all around the same price (only $600-700 for 6 days!). We are looking for any insight or opinion to help us choose. We are planning on honeymooing end of May/beginning of July.

Here are the options:

1. Water's Edge Log Cabin  - Outside of Gatlinburg

It's a beautiful cabin. We love it. It has a hot tub, grill, and indoor jacuzzi. It's just a few miles from Gatlinburg where we can go out to eat and party a little. I'm not sure about the lake access or the lake. Also - this one has no customer reviews.

2. Boone Lake - Near Johnson (1.5 hours from Gatlinburg)

This one does not have a hot tub, but the lake does look more welcoming and it comes with a canoe. It is the least expensive of the 3. 

3. Butler Vacation Cottage - East Tennessee Mountains

Hot tub, grill, canoe, swimmable lake... but might be in the middle of nowhere. 

They all look amazing and I want to be there right now. Please help us decide where to go!